Markup
<div class="tray-table-wrap">
<table class="tray-matrix">
<caption class="tray-vh">Notifications</caption>
<thead><tr><th scope="col">Tell me when</th><th scope="col">Email</th><th scope="col">Push</th><th scope="col">Text</th></tr></thead>
<tbody>
<tr class="tray-matrix__group"><th scope="rowgroup" colspan="4">Orders</th></tr>
<tr>
<th scope="row"><b>A new order arrives</b><small>Once per order.</small></th>
<td><label class="tray-check"><input type="checkbox" aria-label="A new order arrives, by email" checked>
<span class="tray-check__box">…</span></label></td>
<td>…</td><td>…</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
<tbody>
<tr class="tray-matrix__group"><th scope="rowgroup" colspan="4">Account</th></tr>
…
</tbody>
</table>
</div>Every checkbox has an aria-label that joins its row and its column: "A new order arrives, by email". A notification the person cannot turn off (a failed payment, a security alert) is checked and disabled, and the line under its name says why.
Group the rows: each group is a <tbody> of its own, headed by a tray-matrix__group row. Three or four channels fit; with more, give each event its own row of Switches in a Settings Section.
Accessibility
It is a real <table>: scope="col" and scope="row" tie each box to its channel and its event, and the heading of a group is a scope="rowgroup" cell at the top of its own <tbody>, so it names that group's rows and no others. Each checkbox also carries an aria-label that says both ("A new order arrives, by email"), so it makes sense on its own. Space checks it, and the 3px ink ring shows on the box; the label around the box is 44px each way, so it is a finger's size. A box that cannot be turned off is disabled: it is announced as unavailable and skipped by Tab, and the line under the event says why. Give the table a name with a <caption> (hidden with tray-vh, as in the example, when the heading above says the same), or with aria-labelledby on that heading. A quiet Toast is a role="status" region, so the confirmation is read without moving focus.
Do and don't
- Do save each change at once and confirm with a quiet Toast.
- Do word the rows as events: "A new order arrives".
- Don't offer a channel the person has not set up: show "Add a phone number" in that column's head instead.
- Don't pre-check marketing email.